Appendix 8 - Section 321 - Training With Friendly Foreign Countries (Exchanges)

S321

Title 10
Yes
Title 22
No
SC or SA

SC

Subject To BPC LOA

No

Program Duration

Permanent

Program Authority Status

Active

Program Area

Global. Determined that the country’s participation is necessary to achieve the fundamental objective(s) of the exercise.

Program Use

Provides:

  • Construction (Small)
  • Incremental Expenses
  • Training
1. - Program Description
 

S321.1.1. 10 U.S.C. 321 repeals, re-codifies, and replaces the following two programs: Training of General Purpose Forces of the U.S. Armed forces with Military and other Security Forces of Friendly Foreign Countries and Developing Country Combined Exercise Program (DCCEP) into 10 U.S.C. 321, pursuant to P.L. 114-328, Section 1244(a) & (c).

2. - Program Specific Guidance and Restrictions
 

S321.2.1. Purpose of Training and Exercises. The primary purpose of the training and exercises will be to train U.S. forces.

S321.2.1.1. Training With Foreign Forces. If the Secretary of Defense (SECDEF) determines it is in the interest of U.S. national security, armed forces under SECDEF jurisdiction may train with the military forces or other security forces of a friendly foreign country.

S321.2.1.2. Training to Support Mission Essential Tasks. A U.S. armed forces unit will participate in training that supports its mission essential tasks to the maximum extent practicable.

S321.2.2. Elements of Training. Any training conducted will, to the maximum extent practicable, include elements that promote:

S321.2.2.1. Observance of and respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms; and

S321.2.2.2. Respect for legitimate civilian authority within the friendly foreign country concerned.

S321.2.3. Selection of Partners. Training and exercises with friendly foreign countries should be planned and prioritized consistent with applicable guidance relating to the security cooperation (SC) programs and activities of the DoD.

S321.2.3.1. Leahy Vetting. SC provided pursuant to 10 U.S.C. 321 requires Leahy vetting, in accordance with 10 U.S.C. 362 (the “DoD Leahy Law”).

S321.2.4. Authority to Pay Training and Exercise Expenses. Under regulations prescribed pursuant to subsection (e), the Secretary of a military department or the commander of a combatant command may pay, or authorize payment for, any of the following expenses:

S321.2.4.1. Expenses of training forces assigned or allocated to that command in conjunction with training, and training with, the military forces or other security forces of a friendly foreign country under subsection (a).

S321.2.4.2. Expenses of deploying such forces for that training.

S321.2.4.3. The incremental expenses of a friendly foreign country as the direct result of participating in such training, as specified in the regulations.

S321.2.4.4. The incremental expenses of a friendly foreign country as the direct result of participating in an exercise with the armed forces under the jurisdiction of the SECDEF.

S321.2.4.5. Small-scale construction that is directly related to the effective accomplishment of the training or an exercise.

S321.2.5. Availability of Funds for Activities That Cross Fiscal Years. Amounts available for the authority to pay expenses for a fiscal year may be used to pay expenses under that subsection for training and exercises that begin in such fiscal year but end in the subsequent fiscal years.

S321.2.6. Restrictions.

S321.2.6.1. Limitation on Training of General Purpose Forces. The general purpose forces of the U.S. armed forces may train only with the military forces of a friendly foreign country.

S321.2.6.2. Payment of salaries or allowances is not authorized.

S321.2.6.3. The authority to pay any of the training expenses is limited to personnel from “developing countries,” as defined in the memorandum from the official performing the duties of the Under Secretary of Defense (Policy) (USD(P)), “Definition of ‘Developing Country’ for Security Cooperation Programs,” May 15, 2017. DoD Components must also document the specific justification for why the payment of expenses is in the national security interest of the United States.

S321.2.6.4. In rare circumstances, the officials of DoD Components that possess delegated authority under 10 U.S.C. 321 may approve waiver to pay the incremental expenses described above for personnel from a developed country if the official determines that such payment is necessary to respond to “exceptional circumstances” and is in the national security interest of the United States. This “exceptional circumstances” waiver authority is not intended to be an exception that overrides the rule. Per enclosure 1 of the August 9. 2019 USD(P) memorandum, DoD Components must employ the mindset that the payment of expenses for personnel from a developed country is not permitted, instead of the mindset that the waiver authority can be used to “find a way to yes.” “Exceptional circumstances” in Section 321(f)(2)(C) means unusual, specific, and/or unique facts applicable to the specific country in question that are truly remarkable and justify payment of expenses under the circumstances for a specific exercise or training.

S321.2.6.5. Exceptional Circumstances. The “exceptional circumstances” standard is not met solely because it is important for the friendly foreign country to participate, as that should be the baseline standard for any waiver request. “Exceptional circumstances” also do not include the fact that even though the country falls within the category of a developed country, it does not prioritize defense spending; that it would be low-cost for the DoD Component to pay the expenses; or solely because the personnel of the friendly foreign country will not attend if the DoD Component does not pay the expenses. Under no circumstances will a waiver be approved to pay the expenses of a developed country to participate in an event occurring in that country.

S321.2.6.5.1. “Exceptional circumstances” may include an unforeseen financial hardship for the friendly foreign country caused by a natural disaster or national-level financial crisis. This financial hardship could be acute and of short duration or it could be a more extended, chronic situation. In the former, the “exceptional circumstance” would soon expire. In the latter, it is possible the status would extend to the point in time when the World Bank publishes its subsequent annual list of “high income” economies, at which point a country’s status would be reassessed.

S321.2.6.5.2. The “exceptional circumstances” standard could also be met if the DoD Component can articulate how payment of expenses for a particular exercise or training would provide a direct and demonstrative benefit to U.S. military operations, access, and/or influence when the friendly foreign country has demonstrated a willingness to take certain, specific actions favorable to U.S. interests. It is not sufficient if the benefit to the United States is general or speculative, or if the payment of expenses is not directly related to the specific and unique benefit to be provided by the friendly foreign country.

S321.2.6.5.3. Blanket waivers are not permitted. Each request to pay the incremental expenses of a developed country under “exceptional circumstances” and in the national security interest of the United States must be addressed on a case-by-case basis under the specific facts and circumstances of the request. Each waiver request must receive a legal review from the DoD Component’s servicing legal office, and each approval must contain a detailed justification that includes the “exceptional circumstances” present and the national security interest of the United States to be achieved.

3. - Program Key Stakeholders
 

S321.3.1. Under Secretary of Defense (Policy). The Under Secretary of Defense for Policy (USD(P)) serves as the principal staff assistant and advisor to the Secretary of Defense for policy related to 10 U.S.C. 321.

S321.3.2. Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy, Plans, and Capabilities. The Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy, Plans, and Capabilities (ASD (SPC)) acts as the principal agent for the USD(P) in overseeing all aspects of the use of Section 321 authority, including policy and oversight on behalf of the USD(P) to regional and functional offices and the DoD components.

S321.3.3. Defense Security Cooperation Agency. DSCA (Office of International Operations, Global Capability Development Directorate (IOPS/GCD) coordinates, signs, and submits Quarterly Notice on Planned Training letters to the appropriate committees of Congress regarding the quarterly notifications required by Section 321.

S321.3.4. Joint Staff. The Joint Staff (JS) reviews proposals and provides military-related exercise advice to the Combatant Commands (CCMDs) to contribute to the policy oversight of use of Section 321 authority. The JS provides CCMDs with a template and instructions to submit the CCMD’s approved annual Section 321 training reports and quarterly Section 321 notification reports.

S321.3.5. Combatant Command. The CCMD plans and builds Section 321 training events to align general purpose U.S. military training objectives to strategic objectives outlined in the National Defense Strategy (NDS). The CCMD Designs Section 321 training events to maximize the training value to general purpose U. S. military forces and measurably contribute to the achievement of applicable Joint Strategic Capabilities Plans (JSCPs).

4. - Program Planning
 

S321.4.1. Planning Timeline. Approved Annual Requirements are due to the Joint Staff (JS) Directorate for Joint Force Development (J-7) in order to provide DSCA with advance notice of exercises.

S321.4.1.1. Combatant Commanders (CCDRs) must approve Section 321 authority for all known exercises and are encouraged to account for all partner participants and their respective expenditures that might be supported with funding assistance under Section 321.

S321.4.2. Out-of-Cycle Events. Out of Cycle (OoC) events previously approved that require modifications or newly approved emergent requirements that were not included in the annual submission will be submitted in the quarterly notification report.

S321.4.3. JS will submit approved OoC training to DSCA on a quarterly basis to avoid individual processing. DSCA will receive the Combatant Command’s (CCMD’s) quarterly OoC training as one report prior to the beginning of each quarter.

S321.4.4. JS will submit quarterly OoC proposals to the DSCA in accordance with DSCA’s determined deadline.

Table S321.T1. - Quarterly Report and Out-of-Cycle Schedule

Quarter

Reporting Period

Q1

01 OCT - 31 DEC

Q2

01 JAN - 31 MAR

Q3

01 APR - 30 JUN

Q4

01 JUL - 30 SEPT

S321.4.5. An approved exercise submitted outside of the annual and quarterly requirement OoC battle rhythm will be considered an “Urgent Requirement” (UR).

S321.4.6. Approved UR submissions will include a General Officer/Flag Officer signed justification letter that explains the urgency of the requirement and the reason why the submission could not be made earlier and cannot wait for the processing as an OoC in the next quarter.

S321.4.7. If a previously approved proposal requires authority to support an additional country or countries, the exercise must be included in the quarterly report.

S321.4.8. If a previously approved proposal requires authority to support an increase of 20% or greater than the approved level of funding assistance, the CCMD will include that exercise and the newly approved amount in the quarterly report.

S321.4.9. All approved training must first be submitted through the JS (J-7). The JS (J-7) will forward approved training to DSCA to formally coordinate packages.

5. - Program CN Requirements
 

S321.5.1. Section 321 (e) requires the submission of a quarterly report to Congress of planned training engagements in the next calendar quarter. In order to meet this timeline, Congressional Notification (CN) the Combatant Command (CCMD) must notify DSCA 90 days or more before the start of the planned training or exercise. CCMDs must submit approved annual Section 321 proposals to DSCA no later than July 1 annually to meet congressional reporting requirements.

6. - Program Execution
 

S321.6.1. Section 321 assistance may not be provided prior to Congressional Notification (CN) of the planned training. DSCA will provide the Combatant Commands (CCMDs) confirmation that the Section 321 (e) CN is completed, and the exercise and training may proceed as planned. Absent DSCA confirmation that the CN is complete, proposed Section 321 assistance must be postponed or cancelled. Upon approval of a Section 321 CN the requesting command or component is authorized to use Operations and Maintenance (O&M) funds for execution.

7. - Program Reporting Requirements
 

S321.7.1. 386 Report. Section 321 data is included in the annual report mandated by 10 U.S.C. 386.

S321.7.2. Not later than the end of the first calendar quarter beginning after the date of the enactment of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for Fiscal Year (FY) 2017, and every calendar quarter thereafter, DSCA will submit to the appropriate committees of Congress a notice setting forth the schedule of planned training engagement pursuant to subsection (a) of Section 321 during the calendar quarter first following the calendar quarter in which such notice is submitted.

S321.7.3. The House Appropriations Committee (Defense) remains interested in Army Security Force Assistance Brigade (SFAB) deployments and directs that any Congressional Notification (CN) made pursuant to 10 U.S.C. 321 include a description of the number of individuals deployed and their training; the amount, type, and purpose of the training and equipment to be provided to the recipient country’s security forces; the timeline and source of funds; and how the proposed program fits into the overall security cooperation goals of the brigade or country.

S321.7.4. Foreign Military Training Report. All training conducted under Section 321 is subject to inclusion in the annual Foreign Military Training Report (FMTR). See Section C10.21.2. for more information.

8. - Program Legislation and Authorities
 

Section 321 - Training With Friendly Foreign Countries (Exchanges)

Legislation

Subject

10 U.S.C. 321

DoD Forces Training with Friendly Foreign Countries

9. - Program Additional Information